Which Car Brands Hold Their Value Best? A 5- & 10-Year Depreciation Deep-Dive

Introduction – why depreciation matters

Depreciation is still the single biggest line-item in the true cost of ownership. iSeeCars’ March 2025 study of 800 k+ five-year-old transactions pegs the average U.S. vehicle at -45.6 % after five years—up from the pandemic-era lows when used prices spiked iSeeCars. Knowing which brands shed dollars slowest can save (or cost) thousands—often eclipsing interest paid on a typical car loan.

How we compared brands

  • Primary 5-year and 10-year depreciation data: iSeeCars model-level tables and brand roll-ups (Mar 25 2025) iSeeCars.

  • Best-resale-value awards: Kelley Blue Book 2025 Best Resale Value (brand & model) released Mar 4 2025 Kbb.com.

  • Ultra-luxury examples: CarEdge/iSeeCars depreciation calculators for Bentley Continental GT and Rolls-Royce Cullinan CarEdgeiSeeCars.

The best-performing brands at 5 years

RankBrandAvg. 5-yr. depreciation*Why they win
1Toyota~32 % (Tacoma 26 %, RAV4 30.9 %)Reliability, nationwide demand, hybrid dominance
2Porsche20-30 % (911 19.5 %, 718 Cayman 21.8 %)Enthusiast cachet, limited supply
3SubaruLow-30 % range (Crosstrek 33 %)AWD reputation, loyal following
4Honda~34 % (Civic 28 %, CR-V 35.2 %)Long-term reliability, low cost of ownership
5GMC / Chevy trucksHigh-30 %Pickup scarcity keeps resale strong

*Derived from iSeeCars top-25 list; averages rounded. iSeeCars

The worst-performing brands at 5 years

Luxury EVs and big-ticket sedans dominate the “worst 25” list:

  • Jaguar (I-PACE, -72.2 %) Carscoops

  • BMW 7-Series (-67.1 %), Tesla Model S/X (-63-65 %), Land Rover Range Rover (-62.9 %), Maserati Ghibli (-64.7 %) iSeeCars

Factors: high MSRP, tech obsolescence, costly repairs, and—in EVs—rapid battery/charging advances.

Five vs. ten years: how the gap widens

Depreciation slows after year 7, but the compounding hit is huge:

IntervalIndustry avg.Toyota TacomaJaguar I-PACE
5-yr45.6 %26 %72.2 %
10-yr65-70 % (typical)45-50 % (estimate from CarEdge trail)~80 % (EVs age hard)

Even top brands nearly double lost value between years 5 and 10, but still fare better than the market.

Ultra-luxury face-off: Bentley vs Rolls-Royce

Model5-yr depreciation10-yr depreciation
Bentley Continental GT-39 %-70 % (residual ≈ $101 k) CarEdge
Rolls-Royce Cullinan-43.9 %-72.9 % (residual ≈ $105 k) iSeeCars

Despite their prestige (and six-figure MSRPs), both brands trail mainstream performers. Rolls-Royce noses ahead on early ownership prestige but falls slightly behind Bentley over a decade.

Takeaway: Ultra-luxury badges are not value shields; expect ~70 % to evaporate by year 10.

Practical tips to protect yourself

  1. Leverage depreciation, not fight it. If you change cars every 3-4 years, buy lightly-used vehicles from brands with high initial depreciation (luxury sedans, some EVs).

  2. Buy-and-hold? Stick to resilient names. Toyota, Porsche, Subaru, Honda trucks/SUVs consistently top resale charts.

  3. Mind the segment. Trucks and hybrids outclass EVs on resale (-40 % vs. -58.8 % at 5 years). iSeeCars

  4. Run the numbers first. A model with low depreciation can justify a slightly higher sale price or lower finance incentives.

Try it: Plug a high-retention Toyota Tacoma vs. a steep-dropping Jaguar I-PACE into our Car Loan Calculator to see how resale expectations reshape monthly payment choices and break-even points.

Bottom line

Toyota once again secures “Best Brand” for resale value, while ultra-lux EVs and prestige sedans bleed cash fastest. Whether you’re eyeing a sensible RAV4 Hybrid or dreaming of a used Bentley, understanding depreciation lets you pick smarter financing paths—and CarLoanEstimate.biz can crunch those scenarios in seconds.

Back to Blog
5 Key Benefits of Using a Car Loan Payment Calculator Before You Buy Understanding Car Loan Payments: How Your Monthly Payment is Calculated How to Use an Auto Loan Payment Calculator to Find the Best Deal 5 Key Factors That Affect Your Auto Loan Payment How to Save Money on Your Auto Loan: Tips for Reducing Monthly Payments Money Factor vs Residual: Master the Vocabulary of Car Leasing The Largest Auto Lenders in the United States (2025 Edition)